Skip to article frontmatterSkip to article content
Site not loading correctly?

This may be due to an incorrect BASE_URL configuration. See the MyST Documentation for reference.

The Connected River (Part 2) - Exploring

Using integrated monitoring evidence to understand river health and change

UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology

Using integrated monitoring evidence to understand river health and change

This work was carried out as part of the UK Environmental Exposure Hub (EEx Hub), developed through the UKCEH National Capability for UK Challenges (NC-UK) programme and funded by NERC (NE/Y006208/1).

What this notebook explores

Environmental monitoring provides different pieces of evidence about river systems. Part 1 connects those observations through space and time. This part uses the finished dataset to ask:

  • where do we have enough overlapping evidence?

  • how has biological monitoring changed through time?

  • how is river biology associated with environmental pressures?

  • what do repeated observations show that spatial comparisons cannot?

  • what does the longer macroinvertebrate record show about ecological change?

The figures are descriptive. They demonstrate the questions enabled by the integration, not causal effects of individual pressures.

Open the connected dataset

Run The Connected River (Part 1) - Building first. By default this notebook reads the most recent output recorded in connected_river_workspace/latest_method_run.json. Set BCR_RELEASE_DIR only when opening an output stored somewhere else.

The open ChemPop v2 archive is used only for the final historical continuation. Supply an existing ZIP with BCR_HISTORICAL_ARCHIVE, or leave it blank to download and cache the 43 MB deposit.

Source

Meet the connected dataset

Each row begins with a biological survey. Where the matching checks support it, the row also carries antecedent chemistry, route evidence, flow, wastewater and regulatory context. See The Connected River (Part 1) - Building for how those connections were constructed and evaluated.

<Figure size 1500x620 with 2 Axes>
Loading...

From biological surveys to integrated evidence

The diagram follows biological survey rows from candidate routes through the matching checks and into the joined dataset. Review and unmatched rows remain in the saved matching tables.

<Figure size 1800x920 with 1 Axes>

Where do we have evidence?

The first step is to establish where the available evidence supports analysis.

National monitoring and matching support

The maps separate the biological monitoring network, repeat-site coverage and included chemistry. The usable evidence is determined by their overlap, not by the size of any one source dataset.

<Figure size 1550x650 with 6 Axes>
Loading...

Three river stories

These examples show three common situations: consistently supported evidence, changing evidence between years and a persistent chemistry gap. They were selected using completeness and match category.

<Figure size 1600x980 with 9 Axes>

Where are the evidence gaps?

Integrated evidence by hydrometric area

The fingerprint shows which kinds of analysis are supported in different places. Each column uses a common 0–100 availability scale; it is not an overall river-health score. Rows are ordered by included chemistry and repeat-site support.

<Figure size 1350x1269 with 2 Axes>
Loading...

Chemistry coverage through time

Not every determinand is measured in every survey window. The heatmap shows that coverage directly, with missing measurements left as missing.

<Figure size 1250x1350 with 2 Axes>

Monitoring through time

When the notebook is run, the first map is interactive: zoom, pan and hover over sites to inspect the 2025 network. Major river links are drawn behind the monitoring sites, so dense clusters can be separated at local scale. The stored animation gives the annual overview, and the following figure separates changing survey effort from trends at repeat sites.

Monitoring fell sharply across programmes in 2020. That interruption coincides with COVID-19 restrictions and should be treated as a sampling-effort break, not as evidence of sudden ecological change. The latest year can also be incomplete for individual programmes, so trend interpretation uses the saved coverage counts alongside the biological values.

Loading...
<Figure size 1600x920 with 6 Axes>
Loading...

From monitoring to environmental relationships

Spatial pattern versus repeat-site change

The two rows answer different questions. The top row compares site medians and shows the national spatial pattern. The bottom row centres both variables within repeat sites and looks at changes through time at the same site.

The outcomes are WHPT ASPT for macroinvertebrates, RMNI for macrophytes and taxa richness for freshwater fish. Points are site-balanced pressure bins and bands are bootstrap intervals. These are descriptive plots and should not be read as causal effects.

<Figure size 1550x920 with 6 Axes>
Loading...
Loading...
SPATIAL ASSOCIATION ≠ TEMPORAL RESPONSE
Strong differences between sites can reflect river size, habitat, region or monitoring design. They do not show that changing one pressure will produce the same response through time at a particular site.

What this analysis does not establish

A formal model would also need to account for site, year, season, flow, sampling method, nonlinear relationships, spatial dependence and censored measurements. A hierarchical GAM or mixed model could be used for that, with spatially blocked validation and sensitivity checks using alternative matches.

Connect the historical and current record

The same integration approach can reconnect a published historical cohort to current monitoring. ChemPop v2 identifies English river sites sampled through 2018. The open archive is downloaded from the EIDC record, then its site, sample and date identifiers are checked against the ecology archive acquired by this pipeline.

Dataset citation: Bachiller-Jareno, N.; Keller, V.D.J.; Eastman, M.; Edwards, F.K.; Jürgens, M.D.; Scarlett, P.M.; Rizzo, C.; Antoniou, V.; Dean, H.J.; Sadykova, D.; Qu, Y.; Johnson, A.C. (2025). Macroinvertebrate taxonomic abundance, water quality, river flow, air temperature and environmental site descriptors from English rivers, 1965–2018, version 2.0. NERC EDS Environmental Information Data Centre. DOI: Bachiller-Jareno et al. (2025).

Has macroinvertebrate condition changed, 1965–2025?

WHPT ASPT is taken from the same processed ecology archive throughout the time series, so the historical and recent values use one measure. The figures separate the number of sites sampled from the national trajectory and centre values within sites to reduce changes caused by the composition of the monitoring network.

The period comparison uses the same sites and calendar months in 1990–1999 and 2019–2025. It describes change in the observed record; it does not assign that change to a cause.

<Figure size 1600x570 with 3 Axes>
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...

Catchment trajectories

The six panels use the catchments with the most sites in the paired comparison. Lines are shown only when at least five sites contribute to a year.

<Figure size 1550x800 with 6 Axes>

Change by hydrometric area

The map and ranking summarise the same paired-site changes at a broader spatial scale. Areas with fewer than five paired sites remain grey.

<Figure size 1550x920 with 3 Axes>

What did connecting the data enable?

The connected dataset shows where monitoring evidence overlaps and where gaps still limit analysis. It separates changes in monitoring effort from biological patterns and supports both national pressure comparisons and repeat-site change.

Because the integration is reusable, the matched evidence can support further questions without rebuilding the data connection. The Connected River (Part 1) - Building documents the method and its quality checks; this notebook demonstrates the analyses it enables.

References
  1. Bachiller-Jareno, N., Keller, V. D. J., Eastman, M., Edwards, F. K., Jürgens, M. D., Scarlett, P. M., Rizzo, C., Antoniou, V., Dean, H. J., Sadykova, D., Qu, Y., & Johnson, A. C. (2025). Macroinvertebrate taxonomic abundance, water quality, river flow, air temperature and environmental site descriptors from English rivers, 1965-2018, version 2.0. NERC EDS Environmental Information Data Centre. 10.5285/23F194B0-1E21-4F14-BE9C-6EABDCC1FEB7